My New Favorite Musical Trick

I’m not sure if it has an official name. But until someone tells me otherwise, I’m calling it a descending sixth.

I stumbled onto this progression a long time ago.

C   C6  C7  C9  F   Fm  C
0---0---0---x---1---1---0
1---1---1---3---1---1---1
0---2---3---3---2---1---0
2---2---2---2---3---3---2
3---3---3---3---3---3---3
x---x---x---x---1---1---x

It’s basically in C major – even though the C7 and the C9 aren’t actually in C major. But it’s the F-major to F-minor change that’s always grabbed me. That’s a strange pair of chords to see next to each other. The F is certainly in C, but that Fm isn’t. And to have Fm next to an Fmaj is very odd. But works, in that context.

Here it is:

And, if you want to clear away all the brush and get rid of those fancy chords, you can shorten it to C, F, Fm, C and still get the effect.

So that trick stuck around in the back of my head for a few years. But recently I was fiddling around and came up with this thing:

Dmaj7    Em7    Em7♭5     Dmaj7
--x-------x-------x---------x--- 
--7-------8-------8---------7---
--6-------7-------7---------6---
--7-------9-------8---------7---
--5-------7-------7---------5---
--x-------x-------x---------x---

All those 7th’s make things all mellow and smooth. But the A# in that Em7♭5 strictly speaking is out of place – it’s not in the D major scale. But it works, in the progression.

Then I thought. And having thought, I discovered. Firstly, even though the progressions are very different, the trick to making those out-of-key chords work is the same in both cases.

Note that the chords where this trick happens are very similar. F and Fm, from the first progression, are almost identical chords; there’s only a single half-step difference in one note – the major third becomes a minor third. Likewise, Em7 and Em7b5 in the second example are the same chord but for a single half-step change in one note – the fifth becomes a flat-fifth. One note drops a half step. That’s the first part of the trick. And the second part of the trick is that when the next chord, the tonic chord, shows up, the note that had dropped a half-step in the previous two chords drops another half-step to become the fifth of the tonic.

So, even though that note was doing different things in the F/Fm and Em7/Em7♭5 (major/minor third vs. 5/♭5) chords, in both cases, that note is also the 6th of the tonic descending to 5th over three chords.

And, our ears are happy to allow that ‘wrong’ note stop by, as long as it’s moving in the right direction.

Big Star – Way Out West

And, while I was typing this, I remembered one particularly neat example of the trick from Big Star’s “Way Out West”: the intro (and closing) lick is D, Dm, A. Same descending 6th.

And Brandi Carlile does the major-minor-tonic trick in the third and fourth lines of the verses in “Follow”:

                           E
They know not who you are inside
          Em                B
They have never felt your hell

I’m sure this is the kind of thing they teach in first year music courses. But, I’m learning the old fashioned way: messing around while waiting for web pages to load. Anyway, I thought it was neat.

5 thoughts on “My New Favorite Musical Trick

  1. russell

    the name for what you have discovered is voice leading. the line has a logic of its own. all legit. cool!

    Reply
    1. cleek

      “voice leading”….

      huh. i was aware of the term, but assumed it was all about actual voices.

      thanks, russell!

      Reply
  2. Jewish Steel

    Very neat! I was in a band with a songwriter who was addicted to IV-iv-I. That is F-Fmin-C or its equivalent in whatever key we happened to be in. I think the ear is drawn to the chromatic descent of the sixth scale degree. Two sequential half steps is frowned upon in voice leading, so it gets our attention. Beethoven put two half steps in the first theme of his Eroica Symphony. Also to get your attention! “Look! I’m doing something unexpected here!”

    Purely diatonic pieces of music are really more the exception in our vast world of western art music. Practically speaking, the key of C includes every chromatic note in the octave. Savvy composers like you can figure out a way to make anything work!

    Reply
  3. russell

    the major-to-minor thing in particular is used a lot. norwegian wood, for example.

    the thing about musical “rules” is that they are more descriptive than normative. they describe common practices, that are associated wih certain styles or traditions. there is some grounding in some level of objective reality – there is physics behind why som combinations of pitches are more or less dissonant for example – but mostly they were developed as a way of codifying existing practices.

    they are not binding. if it sounds good, it is good.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *