Merlefest 07, Day #2

Late night, lots of rain. But the weatherman says Friday's going to be dry. Awesome. Lazy morning, big breakfast, mimosas. Then, all aboard the Wilkesboro Fire Department shuttle bus and over to the show.

First up for us, the legendary Doc Watson, father of late Merle Watson, for whom the festival is named and dedicated:

Nikon D100, 75-240mm

He's 84, but his voice is still hanging in there, and he's still a better guitar player than I could ever hope to be.

Then, over to the main stage for an all-star jam with Bela Fleck, Sam Bush, Jerry Douglas, Tony Rice and a couple of guys whose names I can't recall right now. They did a bunch of Bela Fleck's tunes, plus a few standards. They kept it mostly on the traditional side, not going too far into the jazzy, progressive stuff Bush and Fleck and known to do. All those guys are incredibly fast and they're also ubiquitous at Merlefest - you can catch any of them playing nearly any time of day. I wouldn't mind if the organizers put a limit on the number of times a performer can appear - get some new blood onto the big stages maybe ?

Nikon D100, 75-240mm

Then, Uncle Earl played a set of traditional bluegrass.

Nikon D100, 75-240mm

After a few songs, they announced that the guy who produced their last album was there, and was going to join them on-stage for a couple of songs. It was John Paul Jones, best-known as the bass player for Led Zeppelin. OMGWTF?

Nikon D100, 75-240mm

He did a couple of songs, playing mandolin.

Nikon D100, 75-240mm

So, that was a little bewildering.

Then, after a short trip back to the campsite for a recharge, we're back for the day's main event:

Nikon D100, 75-240mm

Elvis Costello.

He started with a short solo set of his classics (Every Day I Write the Book, Veronica, Brilliant Mistake, etc.), including a rather disappointing version of Alison, where he jumbled the verses - repeating half of one, skipping another, etc.. Then a bassist and multi-string player came out for a few (hundred) overly-long ballads that few in the audience seemed to know. Applause was polite - nothing like what someone like, say, The Duhks get.

Nikon D100, 75-240mm

He seemed to be picking songs from the country side of his catalog, but they weren't his best, and they seemed to drag and blend into one another - at least for a non-fan like me. Maybe it'd be different if I was familiar with his 30 years of history, but I'm not. And the stuff he did play hasn't inspired me to buy any more.

Eventually, Sam Bush, Jerry Douglas and Jim Lauderdale came out and they managed to get through a ragged version of Friend Of The Devil.

Nikon D100, 75-240mm

That song gave me hope that he'd do some well-known songs that the group could play on. Instead, he told us that they were going to do some songs that they were trying to learn backstage - and if it didn't sound good, "so what?" So, of course the songs were pretty weak, and the guest musicians didn't seem to add much. And after a song or so, Mrs Cleek and I got up and hopped the bus back to the campsite.

The majority opinion of Elvis' show was a) his songs don't really work at a bluegrass festival, b) he chose a lot of weak songs, c) bringing on bluegrass hotshots like Bush, Douglas and Lauderdale and then not using them effectively only showed how out of place he was. One of our party was a fan and thought he did fine. The rest of us weren't convinced. It's a shame - he's a certified legend, with a good number of certified classic songs - and I didn't expect I'd think less of him after seeing him. Oh well.

And that was Friday.

2 thoughts on “Merlefest 07, Day #2

  1. Pingback: cleek » Merlefest 07, Days 3,4

  2. Pingback: cleek » Doc Songs

Comments are closed.